XWL Survey Idea List!!

3. Introducing Match Game Play Reviews, After a Match is Completed Both Competitors Sends a PM to an Admin Rating How Much Fun They Had During The Match (Lets Everyone Know How People Thing They Play, Lets the Admins Know Who Doesn’t Play Fair and Who Gets Their Matches Done)


Honestly think this idea has potential, it's a nice way of getting both sides, seeing how things went, how people can improve, and because it'd be done for all matches, it wouldn't make someone think that they were being singled out for questioning how they play. This should seriously get discussed, could help narrow out ways to improve overall matches experiences.


4. Introducing “Raw Active” Matches on Breakdown, and Having the League Vote on a Name for it

LOVE this idea, totally should do it.


10. Changing the Site Chat to XAT or Make an XWL Group Chat for All the Members on Skype

Not really sure, I get the Skype thing, guess it depends on how majority feel.


14. Introducing a Member and Superstar of the Week

Providing people don't take this too seriously, I'm all for it.

15. Having A Short Blurb Hyping up the Top Matches on the Card

We actually discussed maybe doing this for just Pay-Per-Views again, would make them more special of course, and stick out even more from regular shows.


17. Changing the 3 Finisher Rule

What would we change it to though? I understand wanting change, but what do we have follow in it's place?


20. Introducing More Non-PPV Special Events

We did quite a few of those last year, only so many events we can really do though, of course we're always open to ideas.

1. Bringing Back the X-Treme Title

It'd be cool and all but we were scrapping together contenders for the mid card titles recently so there's no way we'd have enough to do this.

2. Bringing back the PPV Awards.

No. They were open for everyone to do them last time but we only got 5 or 6 votes INCLUDING all the admins. So that left like 3 members or so who voted for them, it's a community thing and so if they aren't going to take 3 minutes to participate then there's no need to have it.

3. Introducing Match Game Play Reviews, After a Match is Completed Both Competitors Sends a PM to an Admin Rating How Much Fun They Had During The Match (Lets Everyone Know How People Thing They Play, Lets the Admins Know Who Doesn’t Play Fair and Who Gets Their Matches Done)

I like the idea, but it probably won't work out. I mean, right now if someone isn't following the rules they usually tell an admin anyway so it's not a huge deal but being required to do it adds more stuff that requires community effort, which has been lacking, and can lead to fraudulent claims against a member because someone lost or something like that.


4. Introducing “Raw Active” Matches on Breakdown, and Having the League Vote on a Name for it

Another community activity thing, I'm for anything that gets the community more involved and together but relying on them/us until we've proven we're more reliable as far as participating is kinda meh in my mind. Yes they've been active about this change stuff but that's because they would like to help make big change, I'd like to see some follow through before.if we start implementing more votes and awards and such.

5. Having More Reviews

I'd love it, but people need to actually contribute. You can't just expect a review without doing one yourself, at least that's how people's mindset should be. I've never reviewed a promo in depth here because I usually don't have much to say besides I enjoyed it a lot plus stating a part I liked, BUT basically I'll start doing this as a test run and I might review more promos outside of this offer but if you review a promo of mine, I will review a promo of yours with an equal effort review. So if you say "That was nice." Ill respond to yours with "It was solid." or something like that. Reviews are an awesome tool that helped me when I first got here and could stil help me now and I'd like to see them back, but not burdened towards two or three people and have people begging for them without doing any themselves.

6. Introducing a Round Robin Tournament Like G1 Climax

Nah, we seem to have enough tournaments anyway.

7. Have More Moderators (Make the Admins Work for Their Spot)

I think we're solid in that area, as far as Admins, I think we all pull our weight in different ways, I may pull mine a little less since I usually don't post anything substantial unless it's a new, not mentioned opinion.

8. Making Matches Matter (Maybe Do a BFG Series to Kick-Start This?)

100% no to the BFG part of this, too many variables for it to work. And to the second part, I want to say yes but with people already ignoring the "fun" part of matches in XWL this would only increase the output of try hardness in matches and it could frustrate people that this turns into a competitive, win above everything else league. I don;t understand this argument considering most of the time a contender has to win a contendership match to get in the title match every other match shouldn't matter cause they should be for fun anyway and I know I goof around a lot in weekly matches trying to have fun and making those matches matter more would hurt me a bit when I'm just trying to have fun. Leave the important matches as contender and title matches.

9. Having More Multi-Contender Title Matches (Triple Threats, Fatal Four Ways, ect.)

Personally, I'd prefer not so many. Opens up the door for complaining about matches and other stuff but mainly it maybe clouds the title picture and someone who deserves it more than someone else loses a match that's really easy to lose since theres multiple parties. I'm not saying no multi-man matches, just a limited number.

10. Changing the Site Chat to XAT or Make an XWL Group Chat for All the Members on Skype

As huge of an issue this is for me, lack of community, I don't think the skype chat would work because it'd become an annoyance always having it popping up and shit. I'm fine for the switch to a XAT chat if it means more of a chance for us all to talk and discuss to each other like how it was when I first joined.

11. Splitting the Superstars into Rankings (Have the IC Title be for Main Eventers/Upper-Mid Carders not in the World Title picture, the US Title for the Actual Mid-Carders, While the Top 3-5 Superstars in the League Go in the World Rankings)

I think the admins are doing a good job of internally picking contenders with what we've had to select from. Separated rankings would just add more onto what the Admins have to do and more for people to complain about as far as how we decide to do it, I'm fine with the thing that was just posted by Krzy as long as it's not the end all be all of deciding contenders which would be the point of a ranking like this and I think those numbers can be misleading as far as how much one promo's or how many times you win. And I don't think either should be the main factor in deciding a contender, and if one has to be I'd prefer the promos as it's someone showing they're invested in their character.

12. Creating a Just for Fun 24/7 XWL Community Title

Not sure what this means or how it'd be done. So no.

13. Having the Admins Pick One Feud and One Superstar and Have the Members Vote Out of the Two for the PPV Poster.

I don't think it should be limited to just feuds. Whoever is doing well and is doing good, consistent work should be up there. Whether it's a champion, contender, superstar, or whatever if they're doing good work they should be able to be on it. That said there is no reason to have repeat appearances in the same year with 12 different posters a year.

14. Introducing a Member and Superstar of the Week

If people don't take it too seriously.

15. Having A Short Blurb Hyping up the Top Matches on the Card

Meh. Indifferent.

16. Having Feuds be Turned into Contender Matches

All for this, if they're doing great and have built themselves up a bit outside of their feud that'd be an awesome reward for having a good feud.

17. Changing the 3 Finisher Rule

Uh, no? Decreasing it is stupid and I'm fine if in big matches to 4 but no other differential.

18. Bringing Back the Newsletter

Only if EVERYONE contributes, it's hard to do and having Krzy do it alone is stupid, I helped last time...can't remember what I actually did for it but I did do something small and Krzy still had to do alot of the stuff.

19. Introducing a Tag Team Tournament

Enough with the tag team stuff, it'll never work. Also, enough with wanting more tournaments, there's already enough.

20. Introducing More Non-PPV Special Events

We had a solid amount this past year, they aren't special if we do many more.

21. NXT for CAWS

Uh, no. Make a CAW league with people from XWL if you'd want this it just wouldn't work and makes little sense.

22. Old School Breakdown

There are already legends that are regular roster members so Idk how this would work, but if we could spin it with maybe classic rematches then I guess it'd work.

23. XWL Royal Rumble

This would never work and doesn't need to even work, we've been fine without it and it would just be a hassle.

1. Bringing Back the X-Treme Title
Not at the moment, if activity picks up I think it could possibly be looked at, however it should be remembered how little people cared for it when we had at and how many people openly shit on the title in their promos.

2. Bringing back the PPV Awards.
PPV votes stopped because barely anyone voted for them, this was just over a month ago. I'm a fan of them personally, but clearly there wasn't enough interest to contribute to them so it's hard to complain about them not being around anymore, same as with the X-Treme Title.

3. Introducing Match Game Play Reviews, After a Match is Completed Both Competitors Sends a PM to an Admin Rating How Much Fun They Had During The Match (Lets Everyone Know How People Thing They Play, Lets the Admins Know Who Doesn’t Play Fair and Who Gets Their Matches Done)
I don't see the need for this, if someone plays cheap just tell an admin about it and it will be looked at, same if someones hard to get hold of/refusing to do their matches. If someone's not doing them the admins should know that when it's not posted in the cards.


4. Introducing “Raw Active” Matches on Breakdown, and Having the League Vote on a Name for it
Incredibly hard to do in my opinion, and I wouldn't be up for it.

5. Having More Reviews
I like reviews, even if it's not a review someone posting just to say they enjoyed your promo is nice. I don't get the idea of "well nobody reviewed mine so I'm not reviewing anyones either", if you don't understand why that attitude doesn't work well then you're a dumb dumb. I liked the Power 10, I didn't enjoy people moaning that they're not higher up on it, and at the time I stopped doing it I wasn't too high(amirite David?) up on XWL either, I might do it again, maybe not though, I don't know yet, shut up. Jerk.

6. Introducing a Round Robin Tournament Like G1 Climax
G1 Climax is top, it would be great, however you'd need to choose the right people to be in it. Krzy tried something like it with the X-Treme Series, which unfortunately didn't work too well due to people being inactive, or dropping their guys mid-way through it.

7. Have More Moderators (Make the Admins Work for Their Spot)
No, to me honestly, 5 admins should be more than enough. David knows I'd do stuff if I'm asked to and if I have the time to do it.

8. Making Matches Matter (Maybe Do a BFG Series to Kick-Start This?)
Basically the G1 Climax. If we had enough guys being amazing consistently then YES. Not at the moment though. If you want better matches then promo them to make it in, you're not going to be booked well if you don't put in the effort.

9. Having More Multi-Contender Title Matches (Triple Threats, Fatal Four Ways, ect.)
I'm not a fan of them, if it made sense then sure.

10. Changing the Site Chat to XAT or Make an XWL Group Chat for All the Members on Skype
Nope, and if that Skype chats made I'm leaving it right away, if you need to talk to me, pm me, XBL message me or Skype me directly.

11. Splitting the Superstars into Rankings (Have the IC Title be for Main Eventers/Upper-Mid Carders not in the World Title picture, the US Title for the Actual Mid-Carders, While the Top 3-5 Superstars in the League Go in the World Rankings)
I don't like rankings, I think it's known that the IC is a bigger title than the US title anyway, plus one admins opinion could be very different to another then a members could be different again, it would be nice to see how far off you are from a title shot admittedly, it's hard to do that though without others getting butt-hurt.

12. Creating a Just for Fun 24/7 XWL Community Title
If it's just the fun then why do you need a title? Just play for fun.

13. Having the Admins Pick One Feud and One Superstar and Have the Members Vote Out of the Two for the PPV Poster.
I don't care to be completely honest, voting just elongate the process and it still won't keep everybody happy.

14. Introducing a Member and Superstar of the Week
Meh.

15. Having A Short Blurb Hyping up the Top Matches on the Card
That's what the scroll is meant to be for?

16. Having Feuds be Turned into Contender Matches
Yes, as long as all parties deserve it.

17. Changing the 3 Finisher Rule
No.

18. Bringing Back the Newsletter
If Krzy has the time and wants to. I don't think it's fair to look at Krzy to do it alone though. If you want it you can always pitch in and help him or do one yourself.

19. Introducing a Tag Team Tournament
See every other tag team thread ever.

20. Introducing More Non-PPV Special Events
There are some every now and then, i I wouldn't want them too frequently though, then they won't be special.

21. NXT for CAWS
NO.

22. Old School Breakdown
Whats the point?

23. XWL Royal Rumble
Speaking from previous experience Royal Rumbles in leagues always work amazing well and nobody ever goes crazy over the result for no reason and nobody ever gets banned because of it...